Tuesday, January 12, 2021

The Problems of Naturalism, Metaphysical and Methodological

    By the post title, I don't mean philosophical problems, so much as practical ones. 

    First, and most telling, is the problem of definition. "Everything is natural" could be the simplest definition of metaphysical naturalism. To pin things down though, what does "natural" even mean here? Without having a clear definition, natural cannot be distinguished from alleged supernatural stuff, let alone claimed as all which exists. 

    Surprising though it may seem, I have often seen metaphysical naturalism asserted with no definition at all. This was not, admittedly, by philosophers, but self-declared metaphysical naturalists nonetheless. Asking for definitions, in my experience resulted only in insults or logical fallacies as responses. 

    Such fallacies I've seen to support it were begging the question and shifting the burden of proof, e.g. "You know it's true!" or "Prove the supernatural!" Well, clearly many people do not "know" it, and the person who asserts this has the burden. They do not accept replies like this from supernaturalists-why should anybody when the same has come from them? 

    Since atheists are generally metaphysical naturalists (some even regarding them as basically identical), this also leads into a weird contradiction among those who assert atheism is merely "lack of belief". Holding a metaphysical naturalist view is a positive assertion though, which if true logically entails (as not only atheists but theists agree) there is no God as generally defined. 

   Positive atheism would be justified  in that case-i.e. God does not exist, rather than simply being unproven as they often assert. Yet they seem unaware of the conflict from what I've seen, or at least will not state this logical conclusion aloud 

    I must reluctantly conclude that two explanations can be given for this. One, they are unable to support their metaphysical naturalism, so despite asserting it they fall back on negative atheism. Two, it is easier to just claim the supernaturalist/theist has the burden of proof, then critique whatever evidence they offer. 

    Both, of course, could also be in play. This however is a contemptible cop-out to me. Atheist philosophers of course have supported positive atheism by and large, plus metaphysical naturalism. So those I'm referring to here are the "Internet atheists" (who ironically often express a disdain of philosophy). 

    Similarly to the above, methodological naturalism has many of the same problems. It's often asserted that science cannot examine supernatural claims as they are not empirical, which is in fact nonsense. Putting aside once again the definition issue, claims of the supernatural are frequently empirical ones. 

    Certainly, some of these aren't, either due to vagueness or other issues. However, many are, and have been tested in the past. Thus the methodical naturalist assertion seen so often here seems like another cop out, and most likely done to avoid conflict. Yet that does not save them-the fundamentalist is not fooled. 

    All this is not to say that I think metaphysical naturalism cannot in fact be defined or defended. Carrier's definition here I think is at least a good attempt at one. He also makes similar points about methodological naturalism. It's the Internet atheists who are vexing on these topics.

    

    


Saturday, October 5, 2019

Appeal to the Worst


In debates about worldviews, different people tend to frame those that rival theirs the most negative way possible. Atheists are probably familiar with hearing something like this given as a description of theirs: 

You were not created for any purpose. There is no meaning behind the fact that you exist. It was the result of blind, natural forces which cannot know or care about your life. When you die, it will be the end. Briefly, the memory of you and whatever achievements your life had may remain. Yet these will also cease to exist in time, until all is gone. It will as if you never even existed at all then. All that, in the span of a moment or less in cosmic time. While you live, it may seem as if your actions are free, but this is an illusion. You are no less the puppet of the natural forces than anything else. Morals too are only creations of the human mind, arbitrary and changeable. Indeed, ever changing. Whatever you do is judged only by other people. There is no ultimate judge that will hold anyone to account if they evade merely human justice. Do what you can manage to get away with, while still living. What else is there?

Yet in truth, an equally unpalatable description can be offered of theism (and sometimes is), such as: 

God made the universe according to his will. No drop of rain falls or bird flies but as he has it. Human beings are given free will, to choose either good or evil. Yet this is not the sole criteria for their salvation, but also worship of God. He who is all-knowing and all-powerful still requires praise by the creatures that in contrast to him are mere specks of dust. With his foresight, he knew which of them by circumstance as much as choice were doomed to Hell. He created them anyway though, knowing fell well this would be the vast majority. Their punishment is eternal, an endless torment of the soul. Many religions came and went, spreading beliefs that were false that led millions astray, as permitted by God. People are rebuked that a wholly loving being clearly made the world, filled with myriad torments for them while living, from diseases to earthquakes or floods that laid waste nations. All these of course will pale in comparison with the suffering that awaits most in the next life. The “good” meant by the word when applied to God has no bearing on that for humans, clearly, nor indeed anything living. Life feeds upon life, and all decays to death. Yet at least plants and animals simply die, with no further pain. For humans is reserved the most awful fate imaginable in the main, because they are corrupt as their creator knew they would be. When a flaw in design can be detected, look to the designer. Yet humanity was created sick, and commanded to be well.


A caricature can never be a substitute for addressing people's actual views.

Sunday, June 10, 2018

Philosophy in fiction

I love both fiction and philosophy. Sadly however they don't mix so well in every case. Now, all of us have a philosophy, even if it's a limited and amateur one. There is nothing wrong with adding your philosophy into a fictional work. In fact, to some degree it is likely inevitable. Most people can't just chuck their views about things out when they write (although the very skilled can present views quite different from theirs).

In some cases though the author seems to view their fiction as a vehicle to present a particular philosophy. This can be very heavy-handed and contrived. I'm going to discuss two examples, bearing in mind I've not read either series entirely. 

The first is The Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind. I've seen much philosophical science fiction, and this is the only philosophical fantasy series I've come across so far. Anyone even slightly familiar with this is probably aware that Goodkind is an Objectivist, i.e. Ayn Rand's follower. 

Many have said that these Objectivist themes only came in later books. In truth though there was some of it from the start. To be sure, they were more understated. Nonetheless, we have Darken Rahl (the main villain, or couldn't you tell from his first name?) being said to live in the "People's Palace" of D'Hara. His "People's Peace Army" has conquered much of the neighboring Midlands. It is not hard to see what all this "People's" stuff references. 

More on the nose is a scene when he visits a sympathetic monarch who has a Box of Orden (there are three, and all together would allow him control over the entire world). Rahl is negotiating to get it from her. She and her guests call in a peasant imprisoned for inability to pay very high taxes. He complains about the injustice and they denounce him with very communist-sounding rhetoric. Again, hardly subtle. 

Objectivism categorically rejects realism in art, including literature, but it's hard to swallow this. Goodkind's fantasy, like most, takes place in a pseudo Medieval Europe, with the expected monarchy and other features, but adding magic. There is no justification of anyone (let alone monarchs) talking like modern communists (or at least how Goodkind imagines they talk). Not to mention that "People's Palace" absurdity. 

Darken Rahl is not called king or emperor but simply "Master", although this changes nothing. He is also a vegetarian, with no clear reason for that. It's not impossible for a vegetarian to still kill human beings (as Rahl did on occasion when people ate meat in his presence) but one suspects that socialism and vegetarianism are simply things that Goodkind dislikes, given Objectivism's condemnation of both.

Later on, a new antagonist leader/country is introduced who are even more obviously communists (though religious ones, which is at least somewhat more realistic in a medieval-type setting). Yet eventually their economy is revealed as like the American one in Atlas Shrugged (undoubtedly an Ayn Rand tribute).

It is thus difficult to imagine how they could field the massive armies we see, or even feed themselves, with a morass of red tape for every decision. Oddly this economy does not seem directly state-run, merely weighed down by bureaucrats having to approve every economic decision and insure it's "fair".

Goodkind seems unable to present his villains being even somewhat nuanced either. All of them are rapists, for example. In regards to their philosophy, it's empty rhetoric that even a child could see through. After all, a king claiming spreading the wealth is good isn't plausible, or calling their palace the "People's".

With the religious communists, it's even worse. It seems much is aimed against Christian beliefs like original sin (it's "spiritual guide" is a monk-like sorcerer). Yet there is only the negative, the idea that human beings are unfathomably detestable to the Creator. Original sin is a concept I too reject, but come on. There is no way Christianity (nor this fictional religion) would have thrived if it had no positive teaching, such as that human beings are sinners, but the divine likeness also.

This isn't simply a matter of whether one agrees with some philosophy presented. I'm neither a vegetarian nor socialist myself. However, it becomes obvious in a case like this that these features are simply dumped into a fantasy world and then presented as things advocated by the villains for the author to rip them apart. Many strawmen are assailed, and the plot suffers. 

My second example is David Weber's Honor Harrington series. Although far better written than Goodkind's work, in my opinion, it also can be heavy-handed in its philosophy. The series is military science fiction, with the main enemies at the start being (hmm, this one's familiar) the People's Republic of Haven. 

Most succinctly, the PRH could be described as the ultimate parody of a welfare state. The majority of people there (Haven is a multi-system polity, like most shown in the series, which Weber calls a "star nation") do not work at all, but simply live on a Basic Living Stipend, or BLS (probably not coincidental that it's close to "bullshit" also in the acronym). "Dolists" is the slang term for them. 

Although nominally a republic, like it's name says, Haven has become in practice a hereditary oligarchy. Heck, the "hereditary" is put right out there before the President's title. Not only him, but also members of Haven's Legislature. This class is called the Legislaturalists. 

It's hard to imagine how this could work, although science fiction is a genre with a lot of leeway. Weber doesn't really try to justify it any more than Goodkind however. He simply says that Haven made up for the deficits having most of its citizens living on the dole caused by conquest and plunder of other star nations. Even so, by the series' start they are in dire straits. 

What's difficult for me to believe however is that it could last this long. The books indicate that the system in Haven has been existing for centuries. A willing suspension of disbelief can only be stretched so far, even in fantasy and science fiction. It was deeply implausible to me that this would remain so long. 

Oddly, despite what the "People's Republic" name would indicate, the economy is later said to be not wholly state-owned, only some parts. When a revolution topples the regime, the new leader understandably realizes they can't go on like this, and uses a war to motivate people into voluntarily going to work again. 

It might have been justifiable to have that many people out of work if the economy were largely automated. This is not the case however, as indicated by the need for them working again. What would happen in the case of that much automation could indeed be interesting fodder for a story. Can a society have most people do nothing to earn their keep? Would it? Sadly, though, Weber seems to be just bashing welfare, without any deeper point. 

It is not only the shallowness of the philosophy which can be a problem, but where this intrudes into the story with a menace. One book has a prisoner from the good guys, the Manticorans, feign being on the Havenites' side while in their custody. He reflects internally upon his guards' sorry intellects, the product of the Havenite education system which focused more on "validating" them than teaching. 

Yes, this is clearly another of Weber's peeves. However my main problem with this was that the characters spends a page or more thinking of this. Never does he say any of it aloud. It's clearly a simple lecture from the author on a subject he feels strongly about, with his villains of course being the strawmen. 

It's difficult to have a message in fiction without becoming preachy or hurting the plot it seems. Some would say just keep your messages out of course. I don't think that's possible, since even then you have implicit ones, it's just we don't really recognize them. Nonetheless it does appear to be something that many authors cannot do well (even when they otherwise are good writers). 

Wednesday, February 21, 2018

The All-Loving God of William Lane Craig

On his website, Craig answers questions posed to him by people all around the world. In one of these, asked by a Muslim from Jordan, Craig defends his Christian view of God as all loving and therefore preferable to the Muslim concept. https://www.reasonablefaith.org/writings/question-answer/is-an-all-loving-god-better

He cites the fact that the Quran says at times that Allah does not love everyone. I haven't myself read these verses, but I'll take their word for it. My problem, however, is with the notion that Craig's god really qualifies as "all loving".

In another post on his site, Craig infamously defends the Israelites slaughter of the Canaanites in the Bible, as commanded by God. Since he follows the divine command theory, God commanding it makes this right.

Ironically in the same post Craig mentions his moral argument for God's existence, yet does not seem to realize this theory is a good example of ethical subjectivism, even going by his own definition. I'll discuss that further in another post however.

The point: where is God "all-loving" in ordering genocide? Really, if this does not refute it, the term becomes empty. More importantly, this makes God very similar to Allah, in clearly not loving every person equally. Unless killing them is a sign of his love?

Craig seems to argue exactly that at least with regards to the Canaanite children, since he believes will be saved, being innocent. Why their adult parents and relatives could not be saved rather than killed though is another issue here.

It is notable just how little mercy a supposedly all-loving God seems to be capable of. Rather than, say, make the Canaanites infertile as punishment for their sins and simply allow them to die out, he has the Israelites simply slaughter them all, children included.

The same could be said for those millions who never heard the word of God at all. Even if God, for whatever reason, doesn't simply reveal himself, just why do they exist? So they all can go to hell out of ignorance? Yet to Craig, it seems, nothing will count against God being an all-loving deity. 

Tuesday, June 20, 2017

Energy and Survival

Many are unsatisfied with the afterlife being a religious dogma, held without empirical evidence. Those of a more scientific bent have dubbed the belief in some afterlife "the survival hypothesis", hoping to give it such evidence.

One tack is to claim that Conservation of Energy supports the idea that some part of us remains alive eternally. The scientific principle says that energy is neither created nor destroyed, and the soul thus may be preserved.

However, this argument has many problems. First of all, claiming the soul (however that may be defined) is "energy" in this regard makes little sense. Many so misuse the term "energy", to find confusion is not surprising.

In science, energy means the capacity to do work. Now, some may define the soul as something like this (for instance the "life force") but most mean the mind or personality. To call this "energy" then does not follow. How is the sum of our thoughts, feelings etc. the "capacity to do work"?

However, as I said, the term "energy" is often used for something entirely different, more like the "life force" that was mentioned. We see this reflected even in popular culture like Star Wars, where the Force has been defined to be "an energy field created by all living things". The latter is just nonsense scientifically, though the Force is essentially like the chi or prana of the East, unsurprisingly as the Jedi are very Eastern influenced.

If by "energy" then the "life force" is meant, though, science called no longer be called to aid the hypothesis. Science long ago discarded this concept of the life force. Life is not a simple force, but a sum of many biochemical processes. In the same way, the soul as our mind is not a scientific idea either. The scientific consensus is that the mind comes from or is a part of the brain that dies along with it.

Assuming we granted that the mind is energy, however, that still does not mean it would survive death, because proponents of this idea neglect an important fact. Conservation of Energy does say that energy is not created or destroyed, true. It is, however, transformed. Death means that our energy is transformed from something animate to inanimate.

The search for an afterlife will have to rest on something else. 

Monday, June 12, 2017

An Examination of Poor Atheist Arguments

I've spent a lot of time on this blog criticizing theism and the arguments offered for its validity. That said, some arguments in favor of atheism also deserve criticism. Poor arguments in favor of the position I hold are still fallacious. A higher caliber of arguments can be made.

The first is what might be called the "single proof" fallacy. If a theist makes a cosmological argument (for instance, from causality) many atheists will respond that even if true, it really doesn't prove that the God they believe in exist. At best it proves some kind of First Cause.

Though true, unless the theist rests their case solely on this argument, the criticism is off the mark. Every case must start somewhere. To do that with where everything came from is a logical starting point. It is a rare theist that doesn't make other arguments as well in favor of the argument, assuming they actually want to convince anyone.

Many atheists, moreover, appear to be strict empiricists, even positivists, claiming that only empirical data has any weight. Therefore, they will then triumphantly declare there is no empirical data for any gods' existence, and thus atheism is validated by that alone.

However, as has long been known, this view has no ability to support itself. For how can any person use empirical data to determine that only empirical data has any validity? Moreover, theists do cite empirical data in favor of God's existence. Fine tuning is one obvious example, but also causality as mentioned earlier. This does mean one must accept it, but we can't claim none is offered either.

It has also been claimed that an argument is not evidence. Even a sound argument for God does not prove that he exists. While it's true that a sound argument can still be false, this is usually related to the empiricist claim up above. Only scientific evidence is held to be valid. Yet not every issue can be a subject of scientific investigation. In any case, many arguments are indeed based on scientific and empirical evidence, for instance both fine tuning or causality as mentioned previously.

There are more still that could be dissected, and they may be yet in a future post. At this time, though, it seems enough to caution against these sorts of fallacious arguments. Even a correct position, which I believe atheism to be, can have poor arguments made for it which should be discarded.

Eternity and Existence

Similarly to the claim of materialism being unable to support meaning, so too a finite existence is claimed as lacking this. Without eternal life, it has been said, there is no point. Everything we are will one day vanish at death, and eventually not even memory or relics of what has been made remain.

To begin with, it seems more than a bit much for any of us here to expect an eternal life for ourselves, or that our works will last forever. All things we see decay and disappear in time. Why should we find ourselves as an exception? 

Even apart from that, however, this claim that a finite existence is pointless strikes me as very odd. To take an analogy, does the fact that a play which moves people, stirring up heights of emotion, become pointless by the fact that it inevitably ends? I don't see how. Nor has anyone explained why this should be the case that I've ever seen. 

In fact, if anything the opposite seems to be true. Something lasting forever could be very bad. This is something that has been shown in many fictional depictions of immortals. They may become utterly bored by this existence, as eventually every experience has been had. Life can become a burden even to mortals. How much more could it be for those that never die? 

It is true of course that existence can be very painful, and people fail to find happiness or suffer from wrongs in this life that seem clearly quite unjust. However, eternal life, whether of reward or punishment as is taught by most religions, does not seem proportionate with our mortal existence. If our life here is finite, any eternal reward or punishment is more than any deserves. 

The very notion of any eternal reward or punishment is problematic when scrutinized. No matter how inventive people get in imagining heavens or hells, at some point every possible reward or punishment will be done. Some are far more simple, as the Bible portrays it, either praising God or burning eternally. Both of those things seem rather pointless. 

How can we appreciate something that has no end in our experience? Even in this life, it is far too easy to take things for granted. Imagine how then it would become if immortal, until as posited above we are bored to death. An eternal joy or suffering can only be a mindless state over time. 

Even an artificial immortality as some believe science promises also seems doubtful. How is any mind capable of holding the memories which would be stored up so long a time? A mind enhanced enough to overcome this would probably leave us so changed we are no longer ourselves. In any case, all the problems with boredom remain. 

So, it appears that eternal life would itself be pointless in the end. 




Saturday, June 10, 2017

Evolution and Reason

It is often claimed by theists that if our reason is a result of evolution, we have no reason to trust its veracity. However, this is not at all obvious. A reasoning capacity has clear adaptive usefulness, such as solving problems like finding food, determining dangers, even winning mates.

It may be argued that this does not account for its usefulness in more abstract areas like philosophy. We must remember however that most people do not turn it to such lofty areas. In any case, side effects of things can outstrip their original functions.

It seems that reason is actually more understandable on atheism. For if, as theists claim, reason is a gift of God, why make it this faulty? I do not think anyone would deny how we can be mislead. This argument against reason having a natural origin turns on the theist. For if they are right, then this is exactly what we would expect to see-an imperfect reason.

One obvious use for reason, on theism, is knowing God. This is the purpose of natural theology. While some theists deny that God can be known by reason alone, many concede it has usefulness, or natural theology would not still be a field of study. Even if they do not, it must be a tool given by God. Why, in either case, give a faulty one?

The question becomes particularly pressing with the first probable use on theism, knowing God. From the vast diversity of belief regarding God, even just within Christianity, it becomes clear that our reason is not a sure guide. On the second use, the faultiness is less problematic, but even so why give us a defective gift?

Possible responses have been that reason does tell us God exists, but we deny because we want to sin. Another is that the manifold differences in regards to religious belief are less than I have made out. On the first, it does not seem to be well supported. What evidence has there been given for this? Many people by all appearances sincerely believe in God and wish to serve him, yet their conclusions about this still can differ greatly. The second is far weaker I believe. We need simply note that polytheism is far more common historically than monetheism.

In conclusion, I believe that far from being evidence for theism, our reason and its flawed nature are far better explained on atheism.

Friday, June 9, 2017

Matter and Meaning

I came across an article on the Huffington Post expressing a view I've often seen, and want to address. Briefly, in it the author, Rabbi Adam Jacobs, claims "nonbelievers" must really at heart believe in something more than matter as their belief system isn't consistent.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rabbi-adam-jacobs/the-god-test-why-really-e_b_1072965.html

Of course, saying all nonbelievers (I don't know whether he includes others besides atheists under that term) are materialists isn't true, but I'll simply ignore that, since it isn't the point of this post. Rather, even if we accepted materialism, what he claims isn't necessarily the case.

Jacobs claims that "nonbelievers" (here meaning materialists) must believe that nothing they ever do will matter, since none has any more significance than another. He says he's awaiting the person who admits this is the case. Well, there are some materialists who think this, but not all. Has he shown they must? I don't see it. How is "everything is matter" equal to "nothing means anything"?

Naturally, he suggests materialists that deny it are deluded. What follows is a brief series of basically "gotcha" questions for materialists. These include asking why materialists won't use the corpse of a loved one for dog food and suchlike. He claims any who said they wouldn't based on respect is simply in denial, with their notion being nothing more than a "subjective, non-intellectual whim" because they are simply "electrical blips in the skull". This again is not argued for, only assumed.

I'm not going to address every question, since they are much the same, but one he raises about art is good for illustrating the problem. He asks what significance on materialism a painting has, as it isn't good for food, etc. This assumes, of course, that only the most basic human urges would make sense on materialism, yet that is not shown. In any case, whether or not we accept materialism is true, aren't all paintings the arrangements of matter? Paint, wood, etc.? We might well ask where this significance comes in for it regardless. Some don't find much significance in many of the paintings out there. It is generally held to be a subjective quality.

There is also the assumption he makes that materialism is arbitrary, blind, random, etc. Again, this is not (at least entirely) the case for all materialists. There is also no reason things (like paintings) can't be composed of various matter which isn't meaningful itself, but has it over and above that, due to the specifics. After all, we can still tell the difference between a painting and jars of paint. Is that not a meaningful difference?

His article closes by saying anyone that rejects this view "may be more of a believer than you think". Assuming, of course, that only a "believer" can find meaning. What believers he does not say, but his religion would presumably be included, plus probably Christianity. So, is any religion sufficient? Even if they disagree about what the meaning is? He does not say.

This method of argument not only commits the strawman fallacy, but also an ad hominem, accusing anybody who rejects his conclusion of being in denial. Yet, as I hope I've shown, he hasn't made clear that his is the only logical conclusion on the philosophy being attacked. To make an analogy, if some gentile claimed he was in denial because his holy book commanded certain laws and Jacobs didn't act on them, I don't think he would agree that is right or fair.

In sum, be courteous to opponents. No one will be convinced by things like this. Unfortunately, it is about what I've come to expect at Huffington Post, from believers and nonbelievers alike. No doubt this is because controversy draws views. Sadly, any real depth is often lost or nonexistent.

Monday, October 17, 2016

Toward A Strong Atheism

For modern atheists in America, most take "atheism" to mean simply lack of belief in gods. This may be distinguished as "weak" atheism here, with the "strong" atheism being belief that no gods exist. However, in philosophy, atheism is defined solely as the "strong" variety. "Weak" atheism would be classed as a type of skepticism. Regardless, in this post I will refer to the view as strong atheism so it can be distinguished from the more common view of American atheists.

The reason for atheism to be defined as lack of belief in gods, and not belief gods do not exist, is said to be either (from atheists) because disbelief is the default position, or null hypothesis or (by theists) to escape any burden of proof. No matter who is right (and both can be correct in different cases) it seems to me a "strong" atheism is viable. Many philosophers have of course defended this since, as I said, atheism is defined that way in philosophy. More specifically, the belief God (as defined by classical theism-a being that is all powerful, all good, all wise and so on) does not exist.

It may surprise many atheists that there are many arguments against the existence of God. They are generally only familiar with arguments for God's existence. Yet while the strategy of only making counterarguments and thus declaring the case for God unproven can suffice, sound arguments that show God does not exist have an even stronger effect. For if the attributes given to God are more than just unproven, but also logically incompatible, then God cannot exist.

I do not think that atheists (for whatever reason) should shy away from holding the position that not only is God not proven, but he does not exist. The philosophical case for this can be and has been made. Philosophical or "strong" atheism is a better position to take, given its firmer and more solid approach. There is no need to settle for God simply being unproven. 

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Absence of Evidence Is Evidence of Absence

Carl Sagan claimed that "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence". From what I gather, it was in reply to people who claimed that lacking evidence for alien life meant this didn't exist. Much as I respect Sagan, however, his claim is wrong. Lack of evidence is evidence that something is not there, it is just not proof. This may seem to be a semantic issue regarding what evidence and proof mean. Nonetheless, it seems to me that being clear in our terminology is very important. Much as in the similar slogan "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" which I examined in my last post (one Sagan also used) a confusion in our terms renders these hopelessly subjective and thus useless.

Evidence means something that tends to prove or disprove, or that grounds a belief. Proof on the other hand is evidence sufficient to establish that something is true, or produce such a belief. Thus, lack of evidence for aliens doesn't prove they don't exist. It does however tend in the direction. Of course a believer in aliens may certainly have some evidence for them as well. We must weigh any evidence for or against this. Often we do not have proof, or at least none which is strong. Therefore, though absence of evidence is not proof of absence, it is evidence of absence. A difference between these is real, and as is said, makes all the difference. They should not be confused in this way. 

Sunday, September 11, 2016

On Extraordinary Claims and Extraordinary Evidence

The phrase "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" is a common one among atheists and skeptics. While catchy, it's unclear what "extraordinary" actually means in this context. Most often it will be applied to claimed miracles and the like. Opponents will alleged this is merely a cover for the bias the person using it holds against such things. Frequently counterclaims will be made such as that accepting this standard would require throwing out many other things which can be labeled extraordinary, such as various historical events/persons or scientific findings.

What seems clear is no one can actually agree on what "extraordinary" means in a given case. For an atheist, claiming Jesus rose from the dead may be extraordinary, since it would require a god able to do things that seem impossible. For a Christian who believes such a god exists, it would not of course. The same can go for many other issues. Many people find the idea that evolution by itself could result in our existence to be extraordinary. People who accept the theory of evolution do not. Etc. 

So is there some way to salvage this? Perhaps. If we take "extraordinary" to mean simply "out of the ordinary" that might work as a definition. However, again what would be "out of the ordinary" seems hopelessly subjective. For many, believers and nonbelievers alike, miracles are out of the ordinary. Yet some believe they happen very frequently. Besides, what would be "out of the ordinary" evidence? Presumably simply hearing someone say how they witnessed a miraculous event would not suffice. That would be pretty ordinary evidence. Yet if we lack "out of the ordinary" evidence (video recordings, perhaps?) most such claims will be unsupported. Naturally believers suspect this is the point of the concept to begin with. 

Another tack may work. Rather than to quibble over the specifics, it might help if the skeptic pressed the believer about whether they would accept similar claims on the same evidence, and point out cases when they have not. For instance, the story of the Resurrection is told in the four Gospels. Yet they are second-hand (i.e. hearsay) and contradictory regarding who actually witnessed it. Contrasting this, the Book of Mormon claims eleven eyewitnesses who swore they saw the Golden Plates from which it was transcribed (one later somewhat recanted, but the rest did not). This would seem far better evidence by far, yet most Christians do not accept Mormonism. Perhaps then we can get into people's reasons to believe or disbelieve. A catchy slogan does not suffice. 

Thursday, September 8, 2016

The Supposed "Pro-Life" Inconsistency

Allow me to clarify briefly before delving into this. Certainly people can oppose capital punishment, war, etc. in addition to abortion. Specifically however consistent life ethics claims they should oppose these things if they oppose abortion to be consistent. I believe this is false. When the issue of abortion came into prominence with the late 1960s, early 1970s in the US, people who supported the right to have an abortion were then named "pro-choice", those against it "pro-life". These labels remain, despite how much the specific arguments have expanded and shifted over time.

In full disclosure, I am pro-choice myself. However, it does not seem at all apparent how having one view necessitates any others in this case. A person can be against abortion, but in favor of capital punishment, without being in contradiction. If they feel abortion is murder (as most do), and capital punishment the just penalty for that, that makes up a wholly consistent position. Obviously people can critique either of those views, as with any other. It does not follow, however, that because someone opposes killing in one instance they must do so universally. Situations differ.

For comparison, one could accuse pro-choice advocates of "inconsistency" for not advocating choice with every issue. The pro-choice person who is not also for school choice (which since most pro-choice people are progressives, would likely be the case) has not been inconsistent. They have two different opinions regarding the issues. I fail to see the inconsistency, and the only exception is if one says all killing is wrong, or every choice valid. Yet very few do this. Unless they do, it is not inconsistent. This does not make the pro-life position right (or wrong), but this particular argument is not valid. 

Sunday, September 4, 2016

Against the Association Fallacy

Much as I noted that the appeal to consequences fallacy comes up often in atheist/theist discourse (see my related post in 2013, "Against the Appeal to Consequences"), the association fallacy has as well. The very claim "atheism killed millions in the 20th century" (generally citing the Soviet Union and Maoist China) or "religion caused the crusades" (insert whatever examples in here that apply) is the association fallacy.

The Marxists responsible for these communist atrocities were indeed atheists, and the Crusades were obviously religious wars (although other factors also had a part). Yet all atheists, or people who have a religion, are hardly responsible for them. It could be argued these were a necessary result of these ideas, so even if individuals are not responsible, these ideas are.

However this too does not seem plausible. Is an atheist who's an Objectivist (a philosophy completely opposed to Marxism) responsible for the atrocities of Marxists? A religious pacifist for those of Crusaders or jihadists? To ever claim this requires painting everyone with the same brush. One must show why atheism or religion causes such misdeeds, regardless of details. To my knowledge this cannot be done. 

Claims of this kind are not only gross overgeneralizations, but a grave injustice for any person who does not share dogmatic, violence-affirming ideologies. On a practical level, these aspersions can do no more than alienate people, as they rightly find it deeply offensive, and discredit the people who make them through doing so in their minds, no matter what valid points may be offered on other topics. It's enough already, I'd say. 

Saturday, September 3, 2016

On Logical Fallacies

Logical fallacies are something to watch out for, obviously. If your logic is flawed, the argument you're making will be too. However these fallacies seem to be often confused with valid logic, or misattributed to others. There are also many logical fallacies, so it's easy to use them accidentally. This leads into the fallacy fallacy-the claim because a fallacy occurred, the entire argument is false. So though logical fallacies must be accounted for, and their use could be the fodder of a critique against others' arguments, they can easily be turned on the user.

When examining arguments, it can be difficult to tell if a fallacy is being used or not. For instance, it's common to see people describe at great length the negative consequences which they claim flow from some contrary position. One may strongly suspect that the arguer is using the appeal to consequences, i.e. claiming this position is false because it leads to bad outcomes. However, it is rare for a person to state this explicitly. So, the principle of charity dictates you take the view that the argument is really "X is false, and these are some bad outcomes which it leads to as well", and not the reverse. Or else you may be using a fallacy fallacy yourself.

However, in some cases I have seen fairly explicit uses of the actual fallacy, such as "I can't believe materialism is true, because that would mean our lives are meaningless" or words to that effect. Some people do not seem to realize this is invalid reasoning in the first place, perhaps. Or else they simply wish to convey the psychological fact that belief in this position would be impossible for them, in spite of any evidence for it.

This can be complicated by the fact that fallacies are sometimes similar to valid arguments. "If you want X, do Y" is valid, not an example of the appeal to consequences. The entire ethical theory of consequentialism rests on this, although of course it can be critiqued on other grounds. Or the ad hominem fallacy, in which a personal attack is claimed to be evidence that a person's argument was wrong, i.e. "You're an idiot, therefore you're wrong." In actual practice, people tend to take this literally, citing any personal attack as an ad hominem fallacy. Thus falling into the fallacy fallacy. Logical fallacies are thus quite the minefield, and should be assessed carefully. 

Monday, August 29, 2016

Big Brother and God

In George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty Four, Big Brother is the tyrannical, unseen leader of the Party. His image is everywhere, displayed on posters, coins and even cigarette packs, not to mention in the omnipresent telescreen bulletins. There is no escaping. No escaping him, or rather his Thought Police. I am not the first, naturally, to find a resemblance with the god of the Bible here. Of course, his real life inspiration is clearly Josef Stalin, who ruled over the Stalin Union much like a god on earth world, to the point of worshipful devotion from the people.

Big Brother is but a pale shadow of the Biblical god however. Vast as his power is, he remains limited by mortal constraints. Though his minions can brainwash and destroy even the memory of a person, at least in death they are free. No such limitation applies to the Biblical god, naturally. He can pursue you into the grave. God's power is unlimited, and so no one could escape, unlike Big Brother. Like the minions of Big Brother, God demands love from his subjects or be horribly punished. Yet Big Brother can only punish by brainwashing, death and destroying the memory of a person. God can do so with eternal torment. 

Thankfully, just as Nineteen Eighty Four indicates that Big Brother is not a person, but merely the embodiment of the Party, so too it does not seem the Biblical god exists as more than a concept. It is also clear that God, or at least his devotees, are well versed in the concept of doublethink. "God loves all people unconditionally, yet if you do not believe in or love him he will torment you forever" and so on. Ignatius Loyola, founder of the Jesuit order once even said "We should even believe that black is white, if the hierarchic Church defined it thus." Orwell uses this same example to define the idea of doublethink: blackwhite, the ability to think black is white, and vice versa, even at the same time. 

Airstrip One, the renamed England of Nineteen Eighty Four, is officially atheist, as was the Soviet Union. This is claimed by many believers to be evidence that atheism causes terrible things. While this ignores the fact that atheism was just one aspect of the Marxist ideology, and does not actually necessitate atrocities nor anything else, I hope this shows that a world with the Biblical god would be far worse. Stalin, Hitler and co., bad as they indeed were, could not hold a candle to how this being is described to us. The claim that such a being is all-good and all-loving simply makes this worse, an insidious doublethink that torments the mind. His devotees are quite real, unfortunately, many with a devotion that would make Big Brother very proud. We can only be happy that at least the object of devotion himself appears to exist only in their minds. 

Return to Blogging

It's been over three years since I posted on this blog. Posts were infrequent in those days, but much has changed in my life since then. I write much more, and some of my thoughts are fodder for blog posts. Much of my outlook has also changed. So it seems like a good thing to take up again. Just an update for anyone who may read this and wonder about the long gap in posting. 

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Against the Appeal to Consequences

The debate of atheism vs. theism (mainly Christianity in the United States) has been characterized by appeals to consequences on both sides. From the atheists frequent arguments that religion leads to ignorance, the oppression of women, violence and other ills are heard. Christians for their part often claim that atheism leads to immorality, meaninglessness, and the atrocities committed by Hitler or Stalin, among others.

Advocates of both positions then make counterarguments to each of these, naturally. Many of these arguments have been false, at least in part, but that is not chiefly my concern here. All of them are committing the appeal to consequences fallacy implicitly, while some do so explicitly-namely, that because of the alleged undesirable results that atheism or theism have, they are thus false. Of course few people want to believe in something that does not comfort them, but that says nothing of its truth or falsity.

I, as an atheist, find Christianity in particular undesirable, though other forms of theism are less so. This personal attitude of mine has nothing whatsoever to do with it being true or not. I am unconvinced that it is, and would be disappointed if it were, but hopefully in that case my intellectual honesty would be enough to accept the truth, even though it was undesirable to me. Our chief commitment, I feel, must be to the truth, discomforting though we may find it.

That said, it is fair to make the distinction that one has been convinced of their position being true, and then critique the opposing view, but that if the other side was right, they would accept the fact. An example will serve to illustrate the disconnect often at work. Some Christians have said that atheism being true would lead them to depression, perhaps even suicide. Whether or not this would happen, the same could be said by atheists.

I would, if the facts to me warranted it, admit that Christianity was true. Most Christians in general assume realizing that will then lead to love of God and devoted worship, as it did for them. However, in my case I would refuse to either love or worship such a God as that of Christianity. Belief in something does not entail love or devotion to it necessarily, as we sometimes forget in these matters. 

Sunday, September 16, 2012

Argumentation Ethics: An Exploration

First, let us define what argumenatation ethics is. Pioneered in 1988 by the German libertarian economist Hans-Hermann Hoppe, it derives from the philosophy of Immanuel Kant. Argumentation ethics argues the following: that whoever engages in argument by definition must affirm life and self-ownership, as these are necessary for engaging in it, thus causing a performative contradiction if one argues against them. However, several criticisms immediately arise. People can and do act without attempting to justify themselves in argument or indeed any way at all. One person can kill another, for instance, without arguing over the rightness of their action-they simply do it. A slave and his master could engage in argument, but that would hardly shows us his master in fact respects the slave's right to his life and person. Further, we can take the case of artificial entities, for instance robots, with an ability to speak and engage in argument but that simply follow their programming.

How to address these criticisms? First, while people certainly do act without attempting to justify or explain themselves, if one retaliates or punishes them for their action, how can they object except by protesting how this is somehow "different." If one initiates coercion, how can they protest that retaliation in kind is wrong, if they committed it? What makes the retaliation wrong, if their aggression was right? This all relies on argument. With the master and slave, although the master may not overtly respect it, he does that by engaging in argument with the slave. Of course that leaves us masters who do not engage in argumentation at all, which is no doubt most. Yet again though, if the slave retaliates against what the master does, he may seek to explain what is "wrong" about this if confronted. Of course, that does not mean argumentation on the matter is going to be forthcoming. In the case of a robot that strictly follows programming, with no independent thought, it would be ludicrous to say that argumentation affirms their own existence and self-ownership; they are drones following commands, nothing more.

Another problem arises simply from what qualifies as "argumenation." Some great apes, for instance, have the capability, however limited, to use sign language. If questioned, they would no doubt object to being, say, experimented upon painfully. This does not apply to most animals, of course, for although the bovine cry of protest while being branded or shot is clear, it seems doubtful this would qualify as argumentation. Like with most libertarian ethical theories, animal rights are given no recognition, although perhaps great apes which can sign might be granted an exception, though here as well the ethic is human-centered, with them being our closest relatives, and their communication ability is a result of that. Great apes may thus fall under this criteria. The issue should, I think, be further explored through study of their behavior and communications. Provisionally, it seems that argumentation ethics has some merit, at least in the context of debate where contrary arguments can be revealed as self-refuting. 

Necessary Illusions?

Free will, objective morality, religion...These are unproven to me. I understand the human need for them, how necessary they are for most people to feel good, and indeed function with others. Yet because it may be necessary for them to believe in these things, it makes them no less an illusion, when not based, as I see it, on evidence and logic. So far I have not seen any convincing proof of these. If anyone who reads this disagrees with me, I would be glad to hear their argument out. What is the purpose of existence? To exist, continue existing and perpetuate it sometimes. The last is an evolutionary drive, but does not have to be fulfilled. Hopefully we can also enjoy what existence we have, although it may not be possible to. So if one feels that existence is not enjoyable, indeed painful, they may end it.

We identify axioms of action, existence, reason, self-ownership, and the senses. One must act to argue against action (by speaking, writing, etc.) one must exist to argue they do not, one must use reasoning to argue against reason, one must have self-ownership to argue one does not own themselves, and one must use their senses to critique sense experience. However, I do not think free will can be assumed a priori in this way.

An objective morality has been sought by philosophers from the foundation of philosophy itself. Natural law theory is a common justification, one that Scottish philosopher David Hume dissected in his A Treatise of Human Nature using the famous "is/ought" problem. Simply put, to say that something is does not mean it ought to be. For instance, the Christian natural law theorists argue that homosexuality is "unnatural" as the purpose of the sex organs is for reproduction, and non-reproductive sexual activity in general also falls afoul of this. However, the fact that our sex organs purpose is to reproduce does not mean they ought to be used only for reproduction. This divide, also called fact/value or descriptive/prescriptive, is termed Hume's Law or more amusingly Hume's Guillotine, as it severs attempts to broach the chasm of the is/ought problem.

These natural law theorists do not take such reasoning to its logical conclusion. Our feet have a purpose, by the logic of natural law, that does not include pushing car pedals, nor riding horseback, or even wearing shoes. This could also be said of clothing, and virtually everything. One could even argue that going against nature in this way is "natural" for us. In any case to call it "natural law" is a misnomer. Gravity is a natural law, which no one can defy. The "natural law" against homosexuality can be defied, and denied. If engaging in homosexual acts were literally impossible, as defying gravity is, that could be called a natural law. Since this is often a theistic idea generally, natural law theorists could argue that free will granted by God precludes making "sin" impossible. Gravity is never held to deny us free will, however. So why did God not create other natural laws which preclude what they view to be sins, along with behavior virtually everyone agrees is undesirable, such as murder and theft? Of course, this assumes free will itself exists, and their answer is most likely that we can only submit to what God has enacted, not go against it.

Even if there were a moral law binding as gravity, however, that does not mean it would have any more of an objective validity. To understand why, let us suppose there were a totalitarian society which had perfected mind control to such a degree that it was impossible to disobey its wishes, on a level with defying gravity. It would thus be true to say their laws were objectively binding in a sense ones are not at present, but no more valid necessarily. If a God created moral laws that its creations were incapable of breaching, for instance every attempt to commit sin thwarted with a mental block, it would no more say God's will ought to be followed, only that it is followed, and cannot be otherwise. Indeed, Nineteen Eighty Four by George Orwell posits Newspeak, the attempt to make "thought crime" impossible to even conceive.

Even assuming one admits all of these are necessary for social order, and indeed an existence with meaning, again that does not, of course, make them correct by itself. A necessary illusion remains illusory. However, they may not only be incorrect, but also dangerous. To hold that people have free will, despite all contrary evidence, may hinder progress in addressing social ills such as crime or mental illness. Understanding that behavior results from prior causes, environmental and genetic, may in fact lead to crime being identified with mental illness. Regardless, greater insight on the causes would likely better our ability to address them. So, the illusion may not be a necessary one, but rather something best overcome.